This page has moved to a new address.

Why Won't God Heal Amputees?

Think Christianly: Why Won't God Heal Amputees?

Friday, May 21, 2010

Why Won't God Heal Amputees?

For the Christian, we know full well that we inhabit a broken and fallen world. Things are not the way they ought to be. And, if we are honest, we all have questions that won't be answered this side of heaven. But sometimes skeptics throw this question at Christians to stop them in their tracks or to "disprove" God--Why Won't God Heal Amputees? What would you say?

My friend Brett Kunkle was asked this question and I think he does a great job responding to it:

"“Why won’t God heal amputees?” The question caught me by surprise.

I had just finished my “Why I Am a Christian” talk at Calvary Chapel Chino Valley’s youth conference in April. After talking with a few students and leaders, a young man approached. He challenged me with this question, explaining his atheist friend had asked it earlier in the week. And he had no answer for his friend.

Apparently, it’s a question atheists make a big deal about. There is even an entire website dedicated to it ( The website claims “this is one of the most important questions we can ask about God.” Sometime, somewhere I had heard the objection but had never given it much attention. Now it was staring me right in the face. Immediate attention was required.

I proceeded in usual fashion—by asking clarifying questions. “What conclusion does your atheist friend draw from this question?” I inquired. He responded, “Well, if God doesn’t heal amputees when we pray for them, then He doesn’t exist.” I followed with a few more questions, gathering the gist of the atheist’s argument.

The atheist claims that alleged healings, like the disappearance of a cancerous tumor or diagnosed disease, seem to be ambiguous. Did God supernaturally heal the person or is modern medicine responsible? Both causes could be offered and both could be disputed. But according to the atheist, if an amputee grew back a missing limb after intercessory prayer was offered on his behalf, this would be a clear case of the miraculous and thus proof for God’s existence. On the other hand, no new limb means no God. A fail-proof test, right? Wrong.

First, I pointed out this atheist’s argument is guilty of...(more)

Labels: , , , ,